I have been through that process and have, I think, come out the other side. I am somewhat calm about my decision although I do waffle daily. Like a lot of macho (

The good news is that the docs think that it is encapsulated and has not metastasized. Now...the choices.
...My docs recommended immediate aggressive action, surgical removal along with radiation. They reason that if the cancer gets out, it can be tough to beat. So nip it in the bud (so to speak...but it is my bud that they are nipping). My life expectancy and decent health are considerations.
...The alternatives
..........beam radiation alone...they say that the chances for metastasizing are much greater with radiation alone than with accompanying surgery.
..........seed radiation (brachytherapy)....they say that I am too advanced for this to be as effective as I need it to be.
So...what's the fuss?
Well hell! The possible side effects of prostate removal are "stick a pistol in your mouth" bad. Yep, that bad.
After the consultation, the one where they tell you about the bad things that can happen.... like erectile dysfunction and being incontinent, you rapidly say..."uh, thanks guys, mind if I get a second opinion on that?"
The second opinion was the same as the first, cause the guys read the same journals, I guess.
Now, after my mild heart problem of two years ago and stents, I am in pretty good health and have an attractive wife, and we enjoy each other's company. We also live a very active lifestyle and I can't see myself wearing adult diapers if worse comes to worse. Sooooo.
I told She Who Must Be Obeyed that I'd rather take my chances with the cancer than have the surgery. And she, being a practical straight shootin' Texas gal, set me straight about how, when one is loved, one has a responsibility to those that love you.
Next Thursday morning it is scheduled....and I chose the human scalpel not the high tech robotic surgery. I figured that I would, if I chose to take my doc's advice, take it all. Nowadays, they zip you in and out and I will be recovering in no time. And, you know what? I am fairly confident that I won't have those "stick a pistol in your mouth" side effects. My wife points to the odds as being good in my favor and points out that I would go "all in" on those favorable odds if I was playing Hold 'em. And I point out that good odds doesn't mean you want to play russian roulette even if the odds are 5-1 in your favor.
Well...we called out "all in" to the dealer and await the deal.